UK finance ministry warns on Scottish independence costs at ?1.5b


London: Britain's finance ministry stepped up its attack on the Scottish government's independence plans on Monday, saying it had not fully budgeted for setting up a new administration that could cost Scottish taxpayers over £1.5 billion ($2.5 billion).

People in Scotland vote on September 18 on whether to end a 307-year union with England and split from the rest of the United Kingdom. Britain's finance ministry has repeatedly argued that Scots would be financially worse off after independence.

On Monday, it said setting up the new public bodies such as a Scottish tax authority, financial regulator and benefits system would cost each Scottish household a minimum of £600, and potentially much more.

"The Scottish government is trying to leave the UK, but it won't tell anyone how much the set-up surcharge is for an independent Scotland," deputy finance minister Danny Alexander said.

He is due to present a more detailed breakdown of the Westminster government's estimates of the costs of Scottish independence and Scotland's budget deficit on Wednesday.

The Scottish government dismissed the report as "deeply flawed".

The British finance ministry said new institutions would cost Scotland at least 1 per cent of its annual economic output - or £1.5 billion - based on estimates made when the Canadian province of Quebec voted on independence.

The actual cost could be far higher.

New Zealand, which has a similarly sized population and economy to Scotland, was currently spending £750 million on a new tax system alone, while a new Scottish benefits system would cost £400 million, the finance ministry said.

A bill of £2.7 billion was possible if the Scottish government pressed ahead with plans for 180 new public bodies, the finance ministry said, based on a cost of 15 million pounds for each new policy department.

But the Scottish government said in a statement many of the public bodies which would be needed by an independent Scotland already existed and would be able to take on new functions.

The Scottish government has said it would be able to generate stronger economic growth after independence, for example by better targeting spending on childcare, education and training, and cutting taxation on company profits and airfares.

It also expects to get large tax revenues from its share of Britain's North Sea oil and gas output.


Set-up charges to cost each Scottish household.


Estimated cost of new Scottish benefits system.


Copyright 2014. No portion of the materials on any pages of the Site may be reprinted, republished, modified, or distributed in any form without the express written permission of Foundation.